According to one very specific, rare bylaw in the NCAA rules manual, there is one important difference.
Before Stephen F. Austin State University played Duke, the Gofundme account for Nathan Bain and his family had barely $2,000. But in the days following his last-second buzzer-beater that stunned the college basketball world, the money is pouring in.
The Bain family now has over $145,000 and counting, as they rebuild their home and church, both demolished in Hurricane Dorian.
Just weeks after announcing that Wiseman could not use a Gofundme for the $11,500 charity donation that the NCAA has mandated he pay, some clear differences explain why one is allowed, and the other is not.
The NCAA specifically mandates that crowdsourcing can not be used to pay back an impermissible benefit, and that’s what Wiseman is dealing with.
However, there is also a specific bylaw that allows for what Bain’s family is doing.
On page 243 of the NCAA manual, under Article 16, the NCAA explains that “an institution may arrange for benefits” if the student-athlete has dealt with “extreme circumstances beyond the athletes control."
The deadly and destructive Hurricane Dorian falls into that category, allowing the Bain family to accept donations.